I am well-traveled and enjoy the appeal of a modest restaurant with good food. Commander Cody's Seafood could use some help in management and customer service. The kitchen staff is more focused on their takeout service than in-restaurant service -- our meal order was lost in the volume of take-out patrons and took an hour to receive. The wait staff needs training in basic customer service -- we experienced poor wait service follow-up, incorrect meal order delivery, and inadequate knowledge of the menu. The food was good, but overpriced for quality of service and quantity. Bottom line: Enjoy Commander Cody's Seafood by calling-in your meal order.
We found this place after arriving in town on a cold Tuesday night before thanksgiving. Food was delicious!!! Mini crab cakes, blackish and squash pumpkin soup. We will definitely go back again!
lot of love and work goes into making the best bbq and seafood in this party of the world. Great music is constantly being played and the corn bread....
I felt transported to a southern hot-spot! You can smell the flavors of great home cookin from all the way out in the road. Bike in. BYOB. Stay a while.
OMG most delious, fresh seafood. So happy that we were able to eat at this very special place. YUM the best! Hope you get to experience it soon .cash or personal check. (No I am not related or paid to give this review)
Commander Cody S Seafood is a US Meal Takeaway based in Shelter Island, New York. Commander Cody S Seafood is located at 41 Smith St, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA.
Please contact with Commander Cody S Seafood using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Commander Cody S Seafood opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.